The Effect of the Expressive Art therapy Package with a Unity-Oriented Approach on Subjective Well-being of Middle-Aged Women

Journal: پژوهشنامه روانشناسی مثبت • • University of Isfahan • ISSN: 2476-4248

Abstract

This research was conducted with the aim of investigating the effect of expressive art therapy package (based on visualizing memories with a unity-oriented approach) on the subjective well-being of middle-aged women. It was a quantitative, semi-experimental research with a pretest posttest design and a three-month follow-up with a control group. The statistical sample was also selected by non-probability sampling method among 47 middle-aged women aged 40 to 55 years in Isfahan City. Those who obtained a lower score in the subjective well-being test (n=26) were randomly assigned to two experimental and control groups. The experimental group received 12 intervention programs in 12 Group Art Therapy Intervention sessions. Each session took two hours. The control group did not receive any intervention. The research tools were Magyar-Moe and Keyes Subjective Well-being Questionnaire and Diener's Life Satisfaction Questionnaire, both groups were evaluated using these tools before the intervention, after the intervention, and after three months in the follow-up phase. For data analysis, descriptive and inferential statistics methods with repeated measurement variance analysis was used. Quantitative findings showed that the effect of this intervention package in the group and test interaction section was significant in the subjective well-being variable and its cognitive (life satisfaction) and emotional levels. However, they were not significant at the psychological and social level. According to these results, expressive art therapy based on a unity-oriented psychology approach can have a positive effect on the mental well-being of middle-aged women.Introduction*Subjective well-being plays a crucial role in overall mental health. Research highlights gender differences in subjective well-being, showing that women often report higher emotional fluctuations. Furthermore, studies indicate a decline in subjective well-being as individuals age, making middle-aged women a critical demographic for psychological interventions. Subjective well-being encompasses individuals' cognitive and emotional evaluations of their lives, including life satisfaction and the balance of positive and negative emotions. The way individuals evaluate life events and memories significantly determines their level of subjective well-being.Memories act as the mind's processing software, shaping daily experiences, emotions, and beliefs. Art therapy provides a powerful medium for expressing such memories. Expressive art therapy uses spontaneous self-expression, imagination, and creativity to help individuals project unconscious thoughts and achieve catharsis. However, to align this therapy with the traditional and collectivist context of Iranian culture, the researchers integrated a unity-oriented psychological approach. Unity-oriented psychology helps individuals analyze their life process cohesively, discovering the connection between past, present, and future events. This approach prevents individuals from rebelling against bitter life events and instead fosters identity integration. Therefore, the present study hypothesized that an expressive art therapy package based on visualizing memories with a unity-oriented approach significantly improves the overall subjective well-being, including cognitive, emotional, psychological, and social dimensions of middle-aged women. MethodThis research utilized a quantitative quasi-experimental design with a pretest, posttest, and a three-month follow-up structure, alongside a control group. The statistical population included all middle-aged women aged 40 to 55 residing in Isfahan City. Using convenience sampling, the researchers selected 47 women from the Bagh-e-Tajrobeh Cultural Center. Based on the inclusion criteria and lower initial scores on the subjective well-being scales, 26 women were selected and randomly assigned to the experimental (n=13) and the control group (n=13). Inclusion criteria required participants to be married, literate, and free from severe psychological or physical illnesses.The experimental group received 12 sessions of expressive group art therapy based on visualizing memories with a unity-oriented approach. Each session took 120 minutes. Sessions included visual journaling techniques such as improvisational collage, illustrating memories of influential people, childhood homes, nostalgic objects, the "Black and White Points of Life," mapping life stages, and creating a "Puzzle of Life." The control group remained on a waiting list. Researchers collected data using the 45-item Keyes and Magyar-Moe Subjective Well-being Questionnaire and Diener's Life Satisfaction Questionnaire. Prior to inferential analysis, researchers confirmed statistical assumptions, including data normality, homogeneity of variance-covariance matrices, and sphericity. Finally, the researchers analyzed the data using repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA). ResultsThe researchers confirmed the necessary statistical assumptions before conducting the main analysis. Normal distribution, homogeneity of regression slopes, and sphericity assumptions were met, justifying the use of parametric tests. Table 1 presents the descriptive statistics for the overall subjective well-being and its cognitive dimension across the measurement stages.     Table 1Descriptive Statistics of Studied Variables by Groups and Type of TestVariablesGroupPretest MPretest SDPosttest MPosttest SDFollow up MFollow up SDOverall Subjective Well-beingExperiment214.7631.14239.2334.89240.4637.35 Control215.9219.25209.8423.83219.9223.13Cognitive Dimension (Life Satisfaction)Experiment18.305.1223.156.9225.466.46 Control19.383.3517.924.0919.075.46Emotional DimensionExperiment40.237.3248.237.6246.4641.23 Control37.696.8339.924.9741.235.01The results of the repeated measures ANOVA demonstrated significant findings regarding the effectiveness of the intervention. For the overall subjective well-being variable, the interaction effect between time and group was statistically significant (F = 4.49, p ≤ 0.05). The Eta squared value indicated that the independent variable accounted for 15% of the variance in overall subjective well-being. The pretest means showed no significant difference between the two groups, whereas the experimental group demonstrated a significant increase in the posttest and follow-up stages.Further analysis of the subscales revealed that the interaction effect of time and group on the cognitive dimension (life satisfaction) was highly significant (F = 9.80, p ≤ 0.01). The effect size showed that 29% of the improvement in life satisfaction within the experimental group resulted from the intervention. Regarding the emotional dimension, the main effect of the group was significant (F = 6.51, p  0.05), indicating a clear difference between the experimental and control groups, accounting for 21% of the variance. However, the time-group interaction for the emotional dimension was not statistically significant.Conversely, the analysis revealed no significant effects for the psychological and social dimensions of subjective well-being. The interaction effect for the psychological dimension (F = 1.32, p ≥ 0.05) and the social dimension (F = 2.57, p ≥ 0.05) remained non-significant across the measurement stages. Therefore, the intervention primarily succeeded in enhancing the cognitive (life satisfaction) and emotional aspects of subjective well-being. ConclusionThe findings of this study confirmed that the expressive art therapy package based on visualizing memories with a unity-oriented approach significantly enhances the subjective well-being of middle-aged women. The intervention demonstrated lasting effects, as evidenced by the stability of the scores during the three-month follow-up. These findings align with previous literature emphasizing the positive impact of art therapy on the well-being and life quality of adults and middle-aged individuals.The success of the intervention, specifically in the cognitive and emotional domains, stems from the program's ability to help individuals confront their past without censorship. By visualizing both joyful and painful memories—such as through the "black and white points of life" exercise—participants learned to accept the entirety of their life experiences. The unity-oriented approach enabled them to stop comparing their lives with others and to recognize the unique "puzzle" of their own existence. This profound acceptance reduced internal conflict with reality, increasing their life satisfaction and emotional well-being. The lack of significant changes in the psychological and social dimensions might be attributed to the brevity of the intervention or the complex phrasing of the questionnaire items measuring those specific constructs.Limitations of this study include the dual role of the researcher as the therapist and the restriction of the sample to women attending a specific cultural center in Isfahan. Future research should apply this unity-oriented art therapy package to middle-aged men and compare its effectiveness with other established art therapy approaches to further validate its clinical utility. Ethical ConsiderationCompliance with Ethical GuidelinesPrior to the start of the research, participants were fully informed about the research objectives and the process of the group sessions. Participants provided informed consent and were assured that their personal information would remain confidential. They were also informed of their right to withdraw from the study at any point without any consequences.Authors' ContributionsAll authors contributed to the conceptualization of the study, intervention design, data collection, statistical analysis, and the drafting of the manuscript.Conflict of InterestThe authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this article.FundingThis research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.AcknowledgmentThe authors express their sincere gratitude to all the women who participated in this study, as well as the management and staff of the "Bagh-e-Tajrobeh" cultural center in Isfahan for their valuable cooperation *. Corresponding author

Subjects & Keywords

How to Cite this Article

Parisa Darouei, Afsaneh Nazeri, Ali Zadeh Mohammadi, et al. (2025). "The Effect of the Expressive Art therapy Package with a Unity-Oriented Approach on Subjective Well-being of Middle-Aged Women". پژوهشنامه روانشناسی مثبت. https://doi.org/10.22108/ppls.2026.131333.2222