Assessment of the Effectiveness of Flexible Work Arrangement on Employee Satisfaction and Performance: a scoping review
2940-2735
Abstract
This scoping review systematically synthesises empirical evidence on the effectiveness of Flexible Work Arrangements (FWAs), including telecommuting, flexitime, compressed workweeks, and hybrid work models, as strategic interventions for enhancing employee satisfaction and job performance. Employing a PRISMA-compliant methodology within the Arksey and O’Malley framework, the review conducts a comprehensive search across multiple academic databases to identify studies evaluating FWAs' impact on employee satisfaction, conceptualised as affective responses to work context and diverse performance metrics, such as task execution, contextual behaviours, and adaptive capabilities. Findings predominantly indicate positive correlations whereby FWAs facilitate increased job autonomy, improve work-life balance, augment engagement levels, and enhance retention and overall productivity, concurrently mitigating stress and burnout symptoms. Specifically, within the South African context, particularly in the software development sector, these benefits are substantiated despite prevalent skills shortages and ongoing post-pandemic adjustments. Nevertheless, FWA outcomes exhibit significant dependence on contextual variables. Key mediating factors include work-life balance, while moderators encompass organisational culture, supervisory support, nature of job roles, and individual demographic characteristics such as gender and socio-economic background. Barriers impeding optimal FWA efficacy encompass stigma associated with flexibility, managerial resistance, technological limitations, and concerns related to career progression, which are accentuated within South Africa’s heterogeneous and socioeconomically stratified workplaces. The review highlights the necessity for the development of tailored organisational policies, comprehensive managerial training programs, and culturally sensitive implementation strategies. It offers implications for organisational practices in urban centres and delineates avenues for future research emphasizing South Africa-specific contextual factors.